Tilgner Report: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(13 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The '''Tilgner Report''' was a report published by {{wp|Kerstin Tilgner}}, leader of the [[Hanoverian Union Party]] and the fifth [[Minister-President of Hanover]]. The report, which primarily concerns reforms surrounding the {{wp|House of Lords}}, the {{wp|United Kingdom}}'s upper house, was published in light of calls for reform as well as for the abolition of the institution which critics deem to be "outdated" and "undemocratic". Authored mostly by members of the [[Hanoverian Union Party]], along with several additional members from both the {{wp|Conservative Party (UK)|Conservative}} and {{wp|Labour Party (UK)|Labour}} parties, the report recommended several reforms for the {{wp|House of Lords}}, namely:
The '''Tilgner Report''' was a report published by {{wp|Kerstin Tilgner}}, leader of the [[Hanoverian Union Party]] and the fifth [[Minister-President of Hanover]]. The report, which primarily concerns reforms surrounding the {{wp|House of Lords}}, the {{wp|United Kingdom}}'s upper house, was published in light of calls for reform as well as for the abolition of the institution which critics deem to be "outdated" and "undemocratic". Authored mostly by members of the [[Hanoverian Union Party]], along with several additional members from both the {{wp|Conservative Party (UK)|Conservative}} and {{wp|Labour Party (UK)|Labour}} parties, the report recommended several reforms for the {{wp|House of Lords}}, namely:


* The imposition of a limit on membership at 600 members with twenty-five seats explicitly reserved for the {{wp|Lords Spiritual}}, 20% for {{wp|crossbenchers}}, and any amount of seats left that are supposed to be occupied by those who otherwise abstain from the {{wp|House of Commons of the United Kingdom|House of Commons}} provided to political independents. The vast remainder of seats would be filled by members of political parties based on the concept of proportionality and depending on the results of the latest general election.
* The imposition of a limit on membership at 600 members with twenty-five seats explicitly reserved for the {{wp|Lords Spiritual}}, 92 for {{wp|hereditary peers}}, and any amount of seats left that are supposed to be occupied by those who otherwise abstain from the {{wp|House of Commons of the United Kingdom|House of Commons}} given to political independents. The vast remainder of seats would be filled by members of political parties based on proportionality and depending on the results of the latest general election.  


* The abolition or reduction of the overall composition of {{wp|hereditary peers}} in the {{wp|House of Lords}}.
* The abolition or reduction of the overall composition of {{wp|hereditary peers}} in the {{wp|House of Lords}} to a fixed total of 92 members.


* The imposition of a term limit for the {{wp|Lords Temporal}} in which those except for the {{wp|Lords Spiritual}} are re-appointed every ten years according to the results of the latest general election. Members must be free of any criminal convictions, are financially solvent, aged no younger than forty, and must mandatorily retire at the age of eighty.
* The imposition of a set of rules for the {{wp|Lords Temporal}} appointed every ten years according to the latest general election results. In this, members must be {{wp|British}} citizens, free of any criminal convictions, aged no younger than forty, financially solvent, have a career in the public or private sector for more than ten years, and must mandatorily retire at the age of eighty. However, hereditary peers are excluded from the ten-year rule and are instead succeeded in their seats by their heirs.


* The provision for resignation or disqualification of a peer in the {{wp|House of Lords}} in which members may be removed either by voluntary resignation, having reached the mandatory retirement age, criminal conviction, or non-attendance for six consecutive months without proper reasoning.
* The provision for resignation or disqualification of a peer in the {{wp|House of Lords}} in which members may be removed either by voluntary resignation, having reached the mandatory retirement age, criminal conviction, bankruptcy, or non-attendance for six whole months without proper reasoning.


* The alignment of the composition of members of the {{wp|House of Lords}} based on the most recent general election with the seats distributed on a proportional basis.
* The establishment of an independent [[HM Appointments and Honours Commission|Appointments and Honours Commission]] to oversee appointments to the {{wp|House of Lords}}, replacing the {{wp|Prime Minister of the United Kingdom|Prime Minister}}'s longstanding role in recommending appointments to the monarch. The commission would comprise ten members, five of whom are partisans and the remaining five being non-partisans, and are appointed on a non-renewable ten-year term.


* The establishment of an independent Appointments and Honours Commission for the purpose of overseeing appointments to the {{wp|House of Lords}}, replacing the {{wp|Prime Minister of the United Kingdom|Prime Minister}}'s longstanding role in recommending appointments to the monarch. The commission would comprise ten members, five of whom are partisans and the remaining five being non-partisans, and are appointed on a non-renewable ten-year term.
Considered to be the most prominent set of reforms concerning the {{wp|House of Lords}}, the report's recommendations were later accepted and subsequently became the main provisions for the {{wp|House of Lords Reform Act 1980}}, marking the first major reform of the {{wp|House of Lords}} in decades since the {{wp|Parliament Act 1949}} came into force. In this, as a result of subsequent negotiations, a notable provision of the Act not previously included in the report stipulated that a majority of candidates nominated by a political party must not come from the same area, thereby ensuring that all 600 members are spread across the {{wp|United Kingdom}} rather than being concentrated in a single area or region. Later, the passing of the {{wp|Church of England Act 1998}}, which officially disestablished the {{wp|Church of England}} as the {{wp|United Kingdom}}'s official church and thus ended the roles of church officials in parliament, saw the twenty-five seats reserved for the {{wp|Lords Spiritual}} abolished and included with the non-hereditary seats.
 
Considered to be the most prominent set of reforms concerning the {{wp|House of Lords}}, the report's recommendations were later accepted and subsequently became the main provisions for the {{wp|House of Lords Reform Act 1980}}, marking the first major reform of the {{wp|House of Lords}} in decades since the {{wp|Parliament Act 1949}} came into force.

Latest revision as of 00:27, 17 November 2024

The Tilgner Report was a report published by Kerstin Tilgner, leader of the Hanoverian Union Party and the fifth Minister-President of Hanover. The report, which primarily concerns reforms surrounding the House of Lords, the United Kingdom's upper house, was published in light of calls for reform as well as for the abolition of the institution which critics deem to be "outdated" and "undemocratic". Authored mostly by members of the Hanoverian Union Party, along with several additional members from both the Conservative and Labour parties, the report recommended several reforms for the House of Lords, namely:

  • The imposition of a limit on membership at 600 members with twenty-five seats explicitly reserved for the Lords Spiritual, 92 for hereditary peers, and any amount of seats left that are supposed to be occupied by those who otherwise abstain from the House of Commons given to political independents. The vast remainder of seats would be filled by members of political parties based on proportionality and depending on the results of the latest general election.
  • The imposition of a set of rules for the Lords Temporal appointed every ten years according to the latest general election results. In this, members must be British citizens, free of any criminal convictions, aged no younger than forty, financially solvent, have a career in the public or private sector for more than ten years, and must mandatorily retire at the age of eighty. However, hereditary peers are excluded from the ten-year rule and are instead succeeded in their seats by their heirs.
  • The provision for resignation or disqualification of a peer in the House of Lords in which members may be removed either by voluntary resignation, having reached the mandatory retirement age, criminal conviction, bankruptcy, or non-attendance for six whole months without proper reasoning.
  • The establishment of an independent Appointments and Honours Commission to oversee appointments to the House of Lords, replacing the Prime Minister's longstanding role in recommending appointments to the monarch. The commission would comprise ten members, five of whom are partisans and the remaining five being non-partisans, and are appointed on a non-renewable ten-year term.

Considered to be the most prominent set of reforms concerning the House of Lords, the report's recommendations were later accepted and subsequently became the main provisions for the House of Lords Reform Act 1980, marking the first major reform of the House of Lords in decades since the Parliament Act 1949 came into force. In this, as a result of subsequent negotiations, a notable provision of the Act not previously included in the report stipulated that a majority of candidates nominated by a political party must not come from the same area, thereby ensuring that all 600 members are spread across the United Kingdom rather than being concentrated in a single area or region. Later, the passing of the Church of England Act 1998, which officially disestablished the Church of England as the United Kingdom's official church and thus ended the roles of church officials in parliament, saw the twenty-five seats reserved for the Lords Spiritual abolished and included with the non-hereditary seats.