Censorship in the Kingdom of Italy: Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
If the guilty party acted for the purpose of political or military espionage, it applies to the penalty of life imprisonment; and, in the cases provided for in the second case, the death penalty. The penalties established in the preceding provisions also apply to those who get the news.<br> | If the guilty party acted for the purpose of political or military espionage, it applies to the penalty of life imprisonment; and, in the cases provided for in the second case, the death penalty. The penalties established in the preceding provisions also apply to those who get the news.<br> | ||
The crime of disclosure of information that has been banned disclosure also includes confidential news, as defined by the public administrations concerned, unrelated to the interests of national security. | The crime of disclosure of information that has been banned disclosure also includes confidential news, as defined by the public administrations concerned, unrelated to the interests of national security. | ||
==== Revelation of information pertaining to military security ==== | |||
The penal code makes researching the Italian Armed Forces or collecting statistical/analytical data about it a crime punishable by up to 5 years unless such activities were first approved by the Ministry of National Defence. These legal sanctions are eligible to be enacted to both foreigners and citizens. | |||
=== Political and economic defeatism === | === Political and economic defeatism === |
Latest revision as of 19:30, 7 July 2023
Censorship in the Kingdom of Italy is implemented or mandated by the Italy's ruling party, the National Fascist Party (PNF). Notable censored subjects include but are not limited to, democracy, ethnic independence movements, corruption, police abuses, anarchism, leftism, liberalism, some gossip, child pornography, news sources that report on these issues, foreign religious content. Censored media include essentially all capable of reaching a wide audience including television, print media, radio, film, theater, text messaging, instant messaging, video games, literature and the Internet. High officials have access to uncensored information via an internal document system.
Censorship in Italy was not created with Fascism, but it became a major issue immediately after the March on Rome. The main goals are:
- Control over the public appearance of the regime, also obtained with the deletion of any content that could allow opposition, suspicions, or doubts about Fascism;
- Constant check of the public opinion as a measure of consensus;
- Creation of a police network of national and local archives in which each citizen is filed and classified depending on their ideas, habits, relationship and any shameful acts or situations which arise;
Censorship fights ideologically andverse and defeatist contents, and any other work or content that could enforce disturbing cultural themes.
Four Basic Points
The Four Cardinal Principles are a set of core values for which debate is not allowed in the Kingdom of Italy. The principles include:
- The principle of upholding the Fascist Way against Communism and Liberalism
- The principle of upholding the leadership of the Duce
- The principle of upholding the greatness of the Italian Nation
- The principle of upholding the Spiritual Worldview
In stating those Four Basic Points, the implication is that political ideas other than those in the list may be debated while observing clearly established limits. Moreover, while the Four Basic Points themselves are not subject to debate, the interpretations of those Four Basic Points are.
Laws against free speech
Italy has several laws and legislative provisions which severely restrict free speech. The oldest ones are included in the criminal code, while others are enacted by other laws.
Revelation of state secrets
Anyone who discloses some of the information of a secret nature or concerning the security of the State shall be punished with imprisonment of not less than five years. If the offence is committed in wartime or the revelation of state secrets has compromised the preparation or the war efficiency of the State or of military operations, the penalty of imprisonment can not be less than ten years.
If the guilty party acted for the purpose of political or military espionage, it applies to the penalty of life imprisonment; and, in the cases provided for in the second case, the death penalty. The penalties established in the preceding provisions also apply to those who get the news.
The crime of disclosure of information that has been banned disclosure also includes confidential news, as defined by the public administrations concerned, unrelated to the interests of national security.
Revelation of information pertaining to military security
The penal code makes researching the Italian Armed Forces or collecting statistical/analytical data about it a crime punishable by up to 5 years unless such activities were first approved by the Ministry of National Defence. These legal sanctions are eligible to be enacted to both foreigners and citizens.
Political and economic defeatism
Anyone who in wartime or in case of serious international crisis spreads or communicates false or exaggerated or biased rumors or news, which may arouse public alarm or depress public spirit or otherwise lessen the resistance of the nation to the enemy, or lessen the solidity of national economy, or performs any activity that may harm national interests, and punished with imprisonment of not less than five years.
The penalty is not less than fifteen years if the fact is committed with propaganda or direct communications to the military personnel, and if the guilty acted as a result of intelligence with the foreigner. The punishment is life imprisonment if the guilty acted as a result of intelligence with the enemy.
Instigation of soldiers to disobey the laws
Anyone who instigates the military to disobey the laws or violate the oath given or the duties of military discipline or other duties inherent to their state, or make military the apology of facts contrary to the laws, the oath, discipline or other military duties, and 'punished, for this' only, if the fact is not a more' serious crime, with imprisonment from two to six years. The penalty is imprisonment from three to nine years if the fact is committed publicly. The penalties are increased if the fact is committed in wartime.
The offence is considered to have taken place publicly when the fact is committed by means of the press, or by other means of propaganda, in a public place or open to the public or in the presence of several persons or in a meeting which, for the place where holding, or for the number of participants, or for the purpose or object of it, has the nature of a non-private meeting.
The crime punishes both the instigation or violation and the apology. The instigation of soldiers to commit a crime is punished with a penalty equal to at least half of the punishment provided for by the offense that he instigates to commit. The conduct may have the character of potential and / or indirect danger for military discipline and may also be potentially and / or indirectly suitable to promote the commission of crimes.
Antinational activity of the citizen abroad
The citizen, who, outside the territory of the State, spreads or communicates false or exaggerated or tendentious rumors or news on the internal conditions of the State, so as to reduce the credit or prestige of the State abroad, or perform anyway an activity such as to harm national interests, is punishable by imprisonment of not less than five years.
Subversive associations
Anyone in the territory of the State promotes, establishes, organizes or directs associations aimed at violently subverting the economic or social systems constituted in the State, or proposing the carrying out of acts of violence for the purpose of terrorism or which are intended to carry out or carry out a 'activity aimed at destroying or depressing national sentiment, is punished with imprisonment from seven to fifteen years. For the purposes of the criminal law, the purpose of terrorism also occurs when acts of violence are directed against a foreign state, an institution or an international body.
Anyone participating in such associations is punished with imprisonment of one to three years. The penalties are increased for those who reconstitute, even under a false name or simulated form, the aforementioned associations, of which the dissolution was ordered.
Subversive, antinational or terrorist apology or propaganda
Anyone in the territory of the state makes propaganda for subversion or terrorism is punished with imprisonment from one to five years. If propaganda is made to destroy or depress national sentiment, the penalty is imprisonment from six months to two years.
Censorship in public communications
This branch of the activity is mainly ruled by the Ministry of popular culture (Ministero della Cultura Popolare, Min.Cul.Pop.). This administration has competence on all the contents that could appear in newspapers, radio, literature, theatre, cinema, internet, TV and generally any other form of communication or art.
Theatre and Cinema
Theatre, and in second instance cinema, is considered, by a longstanding policy of the Government, a fundamental centrepiece of the social life. The establishment of troupes and dramatic societies is widely encouraged and almost every public or private body of some consistence has an its own theatre and (amateur) dramatic society. Tickets are often subsidized by Municipalities or by the Government (most often the Ministry of Popular Culture, but also other Ministries) and both playing and attending to plays (of all levels and qualities) is actively encouraged and presented as one among the most pleasant social activities.
Given the high importance the Government attributes to theatre, it is not surprising that the artistic value of the works is an area of interest of censorship. According to censorship criteria, the many trivial foreign productions are prohibited to circulate to the public, but there is an equal prohibition against those Italian productions which, under the pretext of being a national product, seriously damage art and theatre.
Artistic issues aside, the most common reason for the prohibitions, the cuts and changes, is the offense to public morality and decency. Swear words are not normally permitted and, generally, also the terms considered excessively vulgar are prohibited. Politics is a reason well enforced, but it is less significant from a quantitative point of view; thematically, the main areas to be protected are: social peace, institutions and public authorities, state laws, Italian nationality, race relations, international relations, religion, Armed Forces, privacy, family. The social issues, as opposed to political, mythical and religious ones, can be treated in theatrical plays as long as they do not contradict the government line and not make the exaltation of negative patterns. For plays targeting youth, the severity is determined by the fact that this type of show to be highly educational, that is aimed at training social and artistic education of youth.
Special attention is placed by the censor in vetting jokes praising the Duce and Fascism: in farces cutting is mandatory, nor is it allowed that the Empire is celebrated in low level plays such as operettas. Even excessive flattery is banned from the texts; sobriety in the references to the Duce is a tradition founded by Mussolini and taken up by Debalti. The figure of the Duce has therefore a special place among the topics to be treated with due caution and represents for authors and censorship a minefield. Duce Debalti is in fact very uncompromising with the works that inspire to his person, in the fear of undue exploitment attempts. In the case of references to the Duce, the censor returns through the official channels the opera and refers it to the Duce.
For authors of all works, both theatre and cinema, the general rule (although somewhat flexible) is to avoid the setting of negative representations in a well defined historical-political and geographical reality, with the exception of course of the Fascist propaganda. Finally, it is of course forbidden any play, Italian or foreign, of authors who are hostile to Fascism.
Television
Foreign news broadcasts in Italy are occasionally censored by being "blacked out" during controversial segments. All Italian TV stations are sometimes ordered to delay live broadcasts by 10 seconds, a policy that gives censors time to react in case anti-fascist demonstrators or others staged political protests. Foreign animation is also banned from prime-time viewing hours (5 to 8 pm) to help with domestic animation production. Like Internet censorship, enforcement in television censorship is increasingly ineffective and difficult because of satellite signal hacking systems which give direct access to channels and programs on any satellite that services Europe.
Literature
In literature, editorial industries had their own controlling servants steadily on site, but sometimes it could happen that some texts reaches the libraries and in this case an efficient organization is able to capture all the copies in a very short time. An important note deserves the question of foreign languages: with the general maneuver for self-sufficiency they have been banned, and attempts to use a non-Italian word results in a formal censoring action. Censorship does not however impose heavy limits on foreign literature, and many of the foreigner authors are and remain freely readable. Those authors could freely frequent Italy and even write about it, with no troubles.
Since 1930 it has been forbidden to distribute books that contain Marxist, Freemasonry, Liberal or Anarchist like ideologies, but these books are collected in public libraries in special sections not open to the general public. The same happens for the books that are sequestrated. All these texts could be read under authorization for scientific or cultural purposes, and this permission was quite easy to obtain: the main goal is to keep under control the readers, and only to a lesser extent to prevent them.
Press
The Italian press generally self-censors itself before the censorship commission could do it: the Regime feels quite safe, controlling it by the direct appointing of directors and editors through the specific State-sponsored professional association, the "Ordine dei Giornalisti". The Government issues orders on a regular basis to 'guide' coverage of individual sensitive issues.
Illegal press uses clandestine print and distribution, and are mainly connected with the activities of local political anti-fascist groups. The control on legitimate papers is operated by faithful civil servants at the printing machines and this generated a common joke affirming that any text that could reach readers had been "written by the Duce and approved by the foreman". Each printer must submit four copies of each printed (one at the Prosecutor's Office, two at the Prefecture and one at the police station) before spreading. The preventive control causes the self-censorship by journalists.
Fascist censorship promotes papers with wider attention to mere chronology of delicate political moments, to distract public opinion from dangerous passages of the government. All these manoeuvres were commonly directed by MinCulPop directly. About satire and related press, reactions are not so severe.
The judicial authority may order the seizure of the press in the case of news which include the revelation of state secrets, the disclosure of information of which disclosure has been prohibited, incitement of the military to disobey orders or laws, offence and insult to the Duce and to the Pope, offence and insult to the Kingdom and to the constitutional institutions, offence and insult to the heads of foreign states, offence and insult to the Religion of State, incitement to commit crimes and apology of the same and anti-fascist propaganda and apologetics.
Most important newspapers include "Il Popolo d'Italia", which is the official newspaper of the National Fascist Party, "La Repubblica", founded in mid-1970s by Eugenio Scalfari, with moderate pro-west views, and "Il Corriere della Sera", a stronghold of the liberal elite. The "Corriere", as it is commonly known, is sometimes derogatorily nicknamed "Il Corriere della Serva"; it is a joke about the alteration of the original name, which means "Evening Courier", into the "Servant's Courier", implying that the newspaper is good only for ignorant and non politically-conscious people.
Internet
At least 5,000 websites are blocked from within the country. Certain search engine terms are blocked as well. More recently, through individual negotiations with the Italian government, Wikipedia, Google and YouTube have been opened up for public viewing with certain restrictions for those who access these sites from Italy. The system of blocking sites and articles is referred to as “The Lictor Wall”.
On the Internet, people use proxy websites that allow anonymous access to otherwise restricted websites, services, and information. The Italian largest social media network is called Italian Web Forum (It.: Forum Telematici Italiani, F.T.I.) and it is the official social network, provided by the E.I.A.R., the State-owned television and radio broadcast. The F.T.I., evolving from a servers complex for web forums, offers primarily a free forum base, in which anyone can open any forum, devoted to (almost) any theme, or topic, or hobby, or interest. Alongside the web forums, there are also a social network ("MiPresento") where anyone can have his or her own web page and where it is possible to open also other page types, a blog host (called "MioDiario") and a microblogging network, called "DuePensieri". All these services are completely free, and there are also several platforms for MMORPGs, also partly paid by the E.I.A.R. The large and all-comprehensive social media network was established firstly as a mean to help to develop the internet capacity of Italians; since mid 2000s, the network was maintained and expanded with the western social networks like Facebook or Twitter counter-parts in order to avoid to negotiate with foreign partners to carry out political and police surveillance against antifascists and dissidents.
Censorship in private communications
Any telephone call is at risk of being intercepted and, sometimes, interrupted by censors. Not all the letters are opened, and all those read by censors have the regular stamp that records the executed control.
Chattering en plein air is indeed quite risky, as a special section of investigators deals with what people is saying on the roads; an eventual accusation by some policeman in disguise is very hard to disprove.
Procedure
In most of the small villages, life is not heavily affected by censorship, since the local authorities use a very familiar style in executing such orders. Also in many urban realities, civil servants use little zeal and more humanity. But the general effect was indeed relevant. The censorship work is daily organized, resumed and composed in a note that daily was received by the Chief of Government, by the Duce and by the other major authorities. Notes report what people could think about relevant events, what was the public opinion in Italy, similar arguments.
Social reaction against censorship
Italians are generally well aware of the fact that any communication could be intercepted, recorded, analyzed and eventually used against them; this has been caused, since the 1920s, that censorship is a sort of usual rule to consider, and since the same time most people has used jargons or other conventional systems to overtake the rules.
The little, but still present, open opposition is expressed in satiric ways or with some studied legal tricks.
Subject matter and agenda
Censorship in Italy encompasses a wide range of subject matter. The agendas behind such censorship are varied; some are stated outright by the Government itself and some are surmised by observers inside and out of the country. Regulations include a full database of people who engage in unhealthy professional conduct who are excluded from engaging in news reporting and editing work.
Public order protection
The law against the apology of crimes and instigation of crimes and contraventions is aimed at protecting public order, intended as a good structure and regular social life, which could therefore be threatened by instigation and apology.
Anyone who publicly instigates to commit one or more crimes is punished for the mere fact of instigation with imprisonment from one to five years, if it is an instigation to commit one or more crimes, or with imprisonment up to a year, or with a fine, if it is an instigation to commit one or more contraventions. It is subject to the same sentence also who publicly apologize for one or more crimes.
Anyone who publicly instigates the disobedience to public order, or publicly instigates the struggle between the social classes, is punished with imprisonment from one to five years.
The penalty is increased if the fact is committed through IT or telematic tools. If the instigation or the apology concerns terrorist offenses or crimes against the State, the penalty is increased by half, and increased to double if the fact is committed through IT or telematic tools.
As a separate legal concept, the public official, who, in the exercise of his functions, instigates to the contempt of the institutions or to the non-observance of the laws, the dispositions of the Authority or the duties inherent to a public office or service, or makes the apology of facts contrary to the laws , to the provisions of the Authority or to the duties inherent in a public office or service, is punished with imprisonment up to two years a year or a fine. The provision also applies to people in charge of public service and to ministers of worship.
Political
Censorship in Italy is largely seen as a measure to maintain the rule of the Duce and the preminence of the P.N.F. Censorship helps prevent unapproved reformist, separatist, subversive, or materialist ideas, peaceful or otherwise, from organizing themselves and spreading. The main areas to be protected are: social peace, institutions and public authorities, state laws, Italian nationality, race relations, international relations, religion, Armed Forces, privacy, family. The social issues, as opposed to political, mythical and religious ones, can be debated more openly.
Additionally, censorship prevents Italian citizens from discovering or learning more about past and current failures of the P.N.F. that could create or inflame anti-government sentiment. Measures such as the blocking of foreign governments' websites may also be intended to prevent citizens from learning about alternative systems of governance and demanding similar systems.
Italy also bans materials showing history that conflicts with the official version. Usually, people are allowed to talk about politics on the internet, but certain websites containing anti-government material are blocked.
In recent years, censorship in Italy is used not only for political protectionism but also for economic and military protectionism.
Public decency
Usually, the public decency censorship is employed to prevent political conflicts from happening within the social environment. Some censorship in Italy has been justified as upholding proper morals. This includes limitations on pornography, particularly paedophile press, paedophile pornography, extreme pornography and excessive violence in films.
Except that the fact constitutes a more serious offence, anyone, by any means and with any form of expression, publicly instigates to commit or apologize practices of pedophilia and child pornography is punished with imprisonment from three to ten years. Reasons or purposes of artistic, literary, historical or customary nature cannot be invoked as an excuse. This provision is similar to the public order protection, but it is more specific (and more harsh).
Cultural
Italy has historically sought to use censorship to 'protect the Italian culture'. Continuing crackdowns on banning foreign cartoons from Italian prime time TV, and limits on screening for foreign films are a continuation of cultural-minded censorship. Theatrical and cinema works are carefully screened.
Religious
A number of foreign religious texts, publications, and materials are banned or have their distributions artificially limited. Foreign citizens are also prohibited from proselytizing in Italy, and information concerning the treatment of some religious groups is also tightly controlled. In particular, Islamic proselytism outside Italian-controlled Sinai and Libya is carefully monitored, and all proselytism not authorized by the Benghazi Ulama Council (Arabic: مجلس علماء بنغازي Majlis Eulama' Binghazi; Italian: Consiglio degli Ulema di Bengasi) is banned.
Ministry of Popular Culture
The Ministry of Popular Culture (It.: Ministero della Cultura Popolare, commonly abbreviated to Min.Cul.Pop.) has been a ministry of the Italian Government from 1937. It controls most of the media channels in Italy and supports the Ministry of National Education in the cultural activities.
The Fascist Regime, facing enduring internal threats, since the fascist roll-back of early 1990s has pursued the externalization of threats directed at it, in order both to portray such threats as "illegitimate" (in the sense that they emanate from abroad and violate the norm of the Italian sovereignty) and to portray its repressive actions as "legitimate". The censorship technical activity is carried out by the Ministry itself; the repressive activity is carried out by Division XIII - Technical Services and Telecommunications and Post Police of the Directorate-General of Public Security of the Ministry of Interior.
The editors-in-chief of Italy's major media outlets must attend the Ministry of Popular Culture weekly to receive instructions on which stories should be emphasized, downplayed, or not reported at all. These instructions are not normally known to the public, but are communicated to media workers at the weekly meeting or via secret bulletins. Such directives are considered imperative, and are enforced by disciplines within the P.N.F., as all media in China are required to be loyal to the Party, and are to serve as propaganda organs for the Regime in principle. Operational and reporting freedom has significantly increased in the Itaian media in the recent decade. However, open defiance against the Ministerial directives is rare, as dissenting media organizations and operators risk severe punishment.
Activity and Organization
The activity of the Ministry focuses on five main fields: censorship, propaganda (both at home and abroad), ordinary cultural promotion and activities (both at home and abroad), tourist promotion (mostly abroad) and operating mass media (i.e. web platforms, radio and official tv channels). It also maintains relationships with the cultural Corporations, who provide most of technical personnel.
- Minister and Minister's Cabinet and Staff offices;
- Under-secretaries;
- Secretary General and General Secretariat;
- Service I - Coordination and General Affairs;
- Service II - International Activities;
- Service III - Great events and commemorations;
- Service IV - Research and Inspections;
- Directorate General of General Affairs and Personnel;
- Division I - Emergency Communications: in charge of civil mobilization announcement.
- Directorate General of Accounting Services;
- Directorate General of Italian Press: provides political directives and guidelines, as well as censorship; its fields covers all written activity, but it not covers cultural promotion.
- Division I - Newspapers;
- Division II - Periodical magazines;
- Division III - Books;
- Division IV - Racial Propaganda;
- Division V - PNF Press Office.
- Directorate General of Imperial Press: provides political guidance and censorship to the press of the Italian Empire;
- Directorate General of Foreign Press: deals with foreign press;
- Directorate-General for the landscape, fine arts, architecture and contemporary art;
- Semiprecious Stones Workshop.
- Directorate-General for Antiquities and the Promotion of cultural heritage;
- Directorate-General for Libraries, cultural institutions, copyright and promotion of written culture.
- Central Institute for the Unified Catalogue of Italian Libraries and for Bibliographic Information
- Directorate General of Propaganda, Cultural Exchanges and Proactive Communication of the Italian Culture: it cooperates with Italian bodies operating abroad, such as the C.A.U.R., the Dante Alighieri Society, the Italian Culture Institute and the Fascist Culture Institute; it is primarily responsible for sending propaganda and fascist cultural resources abroad. Subordinate Divisions are coordinated by five Geographical Offices directly subordinated to the Director-General;
- Division I - General Propaganda: propaganda elaboration and diffusion;
- Division II - Radio Propaganda: deals with radio-phonic propaganda abroad;
- Division III - Arts and Cinematography: controls movies and artistic exhibitions abroad;
- Division IV - General and Special Affairs: deals with cultural action against Liberalism and Communism;
- Division V - Cultural Exchanges: deals with bilateral or multilateral cultural exchanges outside educational fields.
- Directorate General of Cinemas and Theatres: provides censorship and political guidance for theatres, cinemas, cinematographic and theatre credit and support, technical assistance to P.S. in order to grant authorization for openings, organization of cinematographic and theatrical events. The Directorate General also operates Cinecittà, but it does not directly produce a State cinematography. It also operates the Istituto Luce and the National Institute of Ancient Drama.
- Directorate General of Toursim: it operates both the National Tourism Agency (Ente Nazionale per il Turismo) and the subordinated Provincial Tourism Agencies.
- Directorate General of Musical Production: it operates the State Discotheque and deals with private dancing locations, also in support to the police.
- Directorate General of Web Communications: operates State-controlled web platforms (such as the Italian Web Forum), as well as the “The Lictor Wall”; it also keeps an eye on the Internet.
- Directorate General of Television and Radio: operates the E.I.A.R. and provide political guidance and censorship to privately-owned television channels and radio broadcasting.
National Commission for Censorship
The National Commission for Censorship (Commissione Nazionale per la Censura) is the central body to apply censorship in some fields (minors education, musical production, cinematoghaphy, national radio and tv production) and to carry out reviews and hear appeals against decisions of the Provincial Commissions dealing with the remaining fields. The Commission consists of five Single Sections (Sezioni Uniche, i.e. of first instance and without appeal) and several Higher Sections (Sezioni Superiori, i.e. of second instance in order to carry out reviews of decisions issued by the Provincial Commission).
Each Section consists of a representative of the Ministry of Popular Culture, a State attorney, a representative of the P.N.F., an official of the Administrative Police Division and a representative of the National Union of Fascist Authors and Writers expert in the relevant field.
The Presiding Committee of the National Commission consists of the Advocate General at the Court of Appeal of Rome, the head of the Administrative Police Division, of all the concerned Directors-General of the MinCulPop and of the President of the National Union of Fascist Authors and Writers. The Committee has the task to elaborate and issue operational guidelines and to implement those elaborated by the relavant Directorates-General.
Section for Media Harmful to Minors Education
The Section for Media Harmful to Minors Education (Sezione per i prodotti mediali pericolosi per l'educazione minorile) is a Single Section subordinate to the National Commission for Censorship. It is responsible for examining and censoring media works allegedly harmful to minors education of all categories (including video games); it works in close relationship with the Ministry of National Education. These works are entered onto an official list; the decision to index a work has a variety of legal implications, ranging from access restriction to outright censorship.
The Section has the responsibility of placing of media harmful to official minors education under legally-enforceable prohibition upon the application of Minister of National Education or of the Secretary of the National Fascist Party or their delegates (actually the Deputy Commander of the Italian Youth of the Lictor), so that these media are accessible only to adults, for the promotion of media education which promotes official Fascist values and for the encouragement of public awareness about media role in minors education.
Media harmful for minors education are those which are harmful to the development or to education of young people as autonomous and socially-compatible individuals. Media that are immoral, excessively brutalizing, or which provoke unreasoned violence or crime are named as examples of this. Content proscribed by law includes content which is proscribed such as instructions on how to commit crime, trivialization of violence and pornography and content which depicts minors in an unnatural situation. As often it may not be immediately apparent whether a particular work or media product has content as proscribed, the Section is able to index such media for the purpose of clarification.
Upon the application of a youth welfare office (Ministry of National Education or the Italian Youth of Lictor) or at the request of another influential P.N.F. official, the Section examines whether a media product has content they consider harmful to officially approved minors education. The decision whether a media work is harmful to minors education is taken by the Examining Committee, which consists of the President (a senior official of the Ministry of Popular Culture) and ten Commissioners, in turn consisting of:
- 1 Official of the concerned branch of the National Union of Fascist Authors and Writers;
- 1 Official of the concerned branch of the Corporation of Editors and Publishers (including telecommunications industry);
- 1 Official of the Lega Fascista Femminile;
- 1 Senior officer of the Italian Youth of the Lictor;
- 1 Senior official of the Ministry of National Education;
- 3 Teachers (1 Teacher for each school grade: elementary-lower middle-upper middle schools);
- 1 Catholic Bishop (or delegate);
- 1 Jewish Rabbi (or delegate).
The hearing, which representatives of the work in question can take part in, is oral and not open to the public; the written reasons for a decision can also be requested by those not involved in the proceedings. Although the Examining Committee works by conensus, formally the decision to index requires a majority; in case of stalemate, the President decides. The Select Committee consists of three Commissioners and has jurisdiction only in cases where harm to young people is obvious. At least one Commissioner must be a representative of authors, one must be of publishers (and related sectors) and one must be of educational agencies (whatever nature: State, Party, Women and Churches). An application for indexing is accepted only if the panel votes unanimously.
The legal consequences of a work being listed on the index are that it must not be sold, provided or otherwise made accessible to minors, it must not be displayed where it can be seen by minors (mainly pornography), it must not be rented out, it must not be advertised or announced in a place where the announcement or advertisement could be seen by minors and, finally, it cannot be spread at all. A critical discussion of an indexed work infringes the advertising ban.
Provincial Commission for Revision of Books and Press
The Provincial Commission for Revision of Books and Press (Commissione Provinciale per la Revisione dei Libri e della Stampa) is concerned with the local press censorship, of political and religious, cultural, economic, financial, medical and technical type. The Commission consists of an official of the prefecture, a police commissioner, a journalist representative of the National Union of Fascist Authors and Writers and an official of the Ministry of Popular Culture. The Provincial Commission may have subordinate Sections in order to comply with the workload. Each Section has the same powers of the whole Provincial Commission (although it operates in a delegation regime) and has dedicated personnel (e.g. the Financial Press Section has a financial journalist or an economist).
Provincial Commission for Revision of Local TV and Radio
The Provincial Commission for Revision of Local TV and Radio (Commissione Provinciale per la Revisione delle Televisioni e delle Radio Locali) is concerned with the local tv and radio censorship, of all types. The Commission consists of an official of the prefecture, a police commissioner, a representative of the Corporations of the Entertainment Operators and an official of the Ministry of Popular Culture.
Provincial Commission for Revision of Theatres
The Provincial Commission for Revision of the Theatres (Commissione Provinciale per la Revisione delle Rappresentazioni Teatrali) is concerned with the local theathrical censorship, of any type. The Commission consists of an official of the prefecture, a police commissioner, a theathre writer representative of the National Union of Fascist Authors and Writers and Authors and an official of the Ministry of Popular Culture.
Censorship works in three ways: it can approve or outright prohibiting a job; It may dismiss it at first, but consider it allowable if reworked by the author as indicated by the censor; It may finally authorize the appropriate modifications or cuts. The script is returned to the sender with the permit; if it is not authorized, the script is accompanied by a mandatory ban, or by a letter with advice and suggestions on changes. The Commission may also visit a work definitively only for a theater in a deteiminata cities, often for art-house halls.