Siedem method: Difference between revisions
(Created base of the page) |
No edit summary |
||
(18 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Region icon Anteria}}{ | {{Region icon Anteria}} | ||
The '''Siedem Method''' is a method for allocating seats in parliaments among member states, or in [[wikipedia:Party-list proportional representation|party-list]] proportional representation systems. | {|class="infobox" style="background-color:#F8F8EF; vertical-align:center" | ||
!style="font-family:Arial Unicode MS; font-size:1.5em; text-align:center" colspan=2|Siedem method | |||
|- | |||
|colspan=2|[[File:SiedemMethodApportionment.svg|link=|260px]] | |||
|- | |||
|colspan=2|[[File:SiedemMethodDistribution.svg|link=|260px]] | |||
|} | |||
[[File:SekideanAssembly.svg|thumb|300px|Current convocation of the [[Sekidean Assembly]] has been elected using the Siedem Method]] | |||
The '''Siedem Method''' is a method for allocating seats in parliaments among member states, or in [[wikipedia:Party-list proportional representation|party-list]] [[wikipedia:Proportional representation|proportional representation]] systems. | |||
Devised by a [[Zhousheng|Zhoushi]] mathematician [[Чaraƌa Siedem]], it is currently used to allocate seats in the [[Sekidean Assembly|Assembly]] of the [[Sekidean Parliament]]. | Devised by a [[Zhousheng|Zhoushi]] mathematician [[Чaraƌa Siedem]], it is currently used to allocate seats in the [[Sekidean Assembly|Assembly]] of the [[Sekidean Parliament]]. | ||
==Motives== | ==Motives== | ||
{{See also|Sekidean Parliament|Sekidean Assembly|Sekidean Union|Inner Sekidean Union}} | |||
[[File:SekideanAssemblyLogo.png|thumb|300px|Logo of the [[Sekidean Assembly|Assembly]] of the [[Sekidean Parliament]]]] | |||
The Siedem Method was devised in early 1990's, when the early [[Sekidean Parliament]] was established. The motives behind this method are, that it serves to assign seats to countries and parties on a regional basis, ensuring, that each country has notable representation in the join parliament, while it still does keep a sense of proportionality. Given the number of coefficients, especially the {{math|S<sub>Σ</sub>}}, {{math|S<sub>R</sub>}} and {{math|Π<sub>Ω</sub>}}, modifying the method allows to update it without the need to change it completely. | |||
This method was designed specifically as a compromise between perfect proportionality per population and per country, creating an equilibrium between smaller and larger states of the [[Inner Sekidean Union]]. Its method ensures, that while the more populous countries have more MPs, average voter of a larger country has lesser voting power than the one of a smaller one. | |||
==Usage of the method== | ==Usage of the method== | ||
===District allocation=== | ===District allocation=== | ||
Seats are assigned based on the formula: | |||
:{{math|x<sub>S</sub> {{=}} ⌊P<sub>C</sub> × (S<sub>Σ</sub> - S<sub>R</sub> × M) ÷ P<sub>0</sub>⌋ + S<sub>R</sub>}} | |||
where: | |||
* {{math|x<sub>S</sub>}} is the number of assigned seats to the district | |||
* {{math|P<sub>C</sub>}} is the voter pool of the district in question | |||
* {{math|S<sub>Σ</sub>}} is the number of total seats available (in [[Sekidean Assembly|ISUA]] currently set to 500) | |||
* {{math|S<sub>R</sub>}} is the number of [[#Assigned section|reserved seats]] (in [[Sekidean Assembly|ISUA]] currently set to 15) | |||
* {{math|M}} is the number of districts (in [[Sekidean Assembly|ISUA]] currently 9) and {{math|P<sub>0</sub>}} is the total voter pool of the parliament. | |||
====Assigned section==== | ====Assigned section==== | ||
Each districts is reserved a said value of seats, marked as {{math|S<sub>R</sub>}}, which the district is guaranteed to gain, even if nobody lived in the said district. In the [[Sekidean Assembly]], the number is currently set to 15, meaning that each district gets a baseline of 15 mandates, while the rest is distributed proportionally. Given, that there are currently 9 districts (member states) sending representatives to the [[Sekidean Assembly]], a total of {{math|S<sub>R</sub> × M}} is set aside from the distribution (in the [[Sekidean Assembly|ISUA]] currently 135) | |||
====Proprotional section==== | |||
After all the reserved seats are removed from the total {{math|S<sub>Σ</sub>}}, the rest is distributed to the districts using the formula {{math|x<sub>P</sub> {{=}} ⌊P<sub>C</sub> × (S<sub>Σ</sub> - S<sub>R</sub> × M) ÷ P<sub>0</sub>⌋}}, where {{math|x<sub>P</sub>}} is the number of seats given to each constituency via proportional representation. The resulting {{math|x<sub>S</sub> {{=}} x<sub>P</sub> + S<sub>R</sub>}} is the number of seats assigned to the district after summing up the assigned/reserved and proportional sections of the seat assignment. | |||
====Underhang allocation==== | ====Underhang allocation==== | ||
Due to the implementation of the [[wikipedia:Floor and ceiling functions|floor function]], some seats remain unclaimed out of the total of {{math|S<sub>Σ</sub>}}, if you add up all the claimed seats. Those [[wikipedia:Underhang seat|underhang seats]] are distributed using special ranking procedure. Districts are given ranks from 1 to {{math|n}}, based on the coefficient, {{math|Q<sub>S</sub>}} for which it is set, that {{math|Q<sub>S</sub> {{=}} x<sub>S</sub> ÷ P<sub>C</sub>}}, with the highest {{math|Q<sub>S</sub>}} being ranked as "1", second highest as "2" etc. | |||
After all the districts have been ranked, the seats are assigned by adding one seat to each district, starting at the district ranked as "1" and going down, until the overhang seats run out. Each districts resulting number {{math|x}} is the final number, that decides how many deputies the district elects on election day. | |||
This method ensures, that those seats are assigned to underrepresented districts, at least partially levelling the artificially created disproportionality created by the section of reserved seats. | |||
===Seat allocation=== | ===Seat allocation=== | ||
The elections are done using the [[wikipedia:Party-list proportional representation|party-list proportional representation]]. If there is an [[wikipedia:Electoral threshold|electoral threshold]], it is applied already in the first scrutinia. | |||
====First scrutinia==== | ====First scrutinia==== | ||
After votes in each district are morphed into percent points (marked as {{math|Π<sub>P</sub>}}). Those percentages, if they are bigger than the threshold ({{math|Π<sub>Ω</sub>}}, currently set at 4%), are then used in latter calculations. Sum of all percentages, that passed the electoral threshold, are marked as {{math|Π<sub>E</sub>}}. Seats are the distributed using the formula: | |||
:{{math|R<sub>P</sub> {{=}} ⌊(Π<sub>E</sub> × {{math|x}}) ÷ Π<sub>E</sub>⌋}} | |||
Usually between 92% and 97% of the seats are distributed in the first scrutinia, with the rest being transferred to a second scrutinia for parliament-wide arrangement. | |||
====Second scrutinia==== | ====Second scrutinia==== | ||
When all the {{math|R<sub>P</sub>}} have been summed up for each district, the remaining seats, marked as {{math|R<sub>R</sub>}}, are summed up nationwide, marked as {{math|R<sub>S</sub>}}. Those [[wikipedia:Underhang seat|underhang seats]] are then given in descending order from the party with most seats to the one with the least, eventually looping from the least to the most again. Multiple rounds of assigning can be done before the second scrutinia seats run out. Those seats for each party are marked as {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}}. | |||
After the alliances are set, it is decided, which district the candidates are elected from using the {{math|R<sub>R</sub>}}. Districts are ranked using the {{math|R<sub>R</sub>}}, from the lowest to the highest, and parties are ranked using the {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}}, from the highest to the lowest. Then, district ranked first in {{math|R<sub>R</sub>}} gets one additional mandate for a party with the highest {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}} (unless the party scored under the electoral threshold in the region). Then, the district ranked second recieves one additional mandate for the party with the highest {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}} (note: {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}} decreases with adding of mandates). After {{math|R<sub>R</sub>}} reaches 0 in a district, the district is removed from the list of second scrutinia adding mandates. If {{math|R<sub>Π</sub>}} reaches 0, the party is removed from the distribution of overhang seats from then on. | |||
It applies, that {{math|Σ(R<sub>Π</sub>) {{=}} Σ(R<sub>R</sub>)}}, so the last unassigned party mandate is assigned to the last country mandate, effectively filling all the mandates, while keeping both the vote and district proportionallity as set by the criteria. | |||
{{Template:Sekidean info pages}} | {{Template:Sekidean info pages}} | ||
{{Template:Anteria info pages}} | {{Template:Anteria info pages}} | ||
[[Category:Election method]] |
Latest revision as of 16:56, 12 October 2022
Siedem method | |
---|---|
The Siedem Method is a method for allocating seats in parliaments among member states, or in party-list proportional representation systems.
Devised by a Zhoushi mathematician Чaraƌa Siedem, it is currently used to allocate seats in the Assembly of the Sekidean Parliament.
Motives
The Siedem Method was devised in early 1990's, when the early Sekidean Parliament was established. The motives behind this method are, that it serves to assign seats to countries and parties on a regional basis, ensuring, that each country has notable representation in the join parliament, while it still does keep a sense of proportionality. Given the number of coefficients, especially the SΣ, SR and ΠΩ, modifying the method allows to update it without the need to change it completely.
This method was designed specifically as a compromise between perfect proportionality per population and per country, creating an equilibrium between smaller and larger states of the Inner Sekidean Union. Its method ensures, that while the more populous countries have more MPs, average voter of a larger country has lesser voting power than the one of a smaller one.
Usage of the method
District allocation
Seats are assigned based on the formula:
xS = ⌊PC × (SΣ - SR × M) ÷ P0⌋ + SR
where:
xS is the number of assigned seats to the district
PC is the voter pool of the district in question
SΣ is the number of total seats available (in ISUA currently set to 500)
SR is the number of reserved seats (in ISUA currently set to 15)
M is the number of districts (in ISUA currently 9) and P0 is the total voter pool of the parliament.
Assigned section
Each districts is reserved a said value of seats, marked as SR, which the district is guaranteed to gain, even if nobody lived in the said district. In the Sekidean Assembly, the number is currently set to 15, meaning that each district gets a baseline of 15 mandates, while the rest is distributed proportionally. Given, that there are currently 9 districts (member states) sending representatives to the Sekidean Assembly, a total of SR × M is set aside from the distribution (in the ISUA currently 135)
Proprotional section
After all the reserved seats are removed from the total SΣ, the rest is distributed to the districts using the formula xP = ⌊PC × (SΣ - SR × M) ÷ P0⌋, where xP is the number of seats given to each constituency via proportional representation. The resulting xS = xP + SR is the number of seats assigned to the district after summing up the assigned/reserved and proportional sections of the seat assignment.
Underhang allocation
Due to the implementation of the floor function, some seats remain unclaimed out of the total of SΣ, if you add up all the claimed seats. Those underhang seats are distributed using special ranking procedure. Districts are given ranks from 1 to n, based on the coefficient, QS for which it is set, that QS = xS ÷ PC, with the highest QS being ranked as "1", second highest as "2" etc.
After all the districts have been ranked, the seats are assigned by adding one seat to each district, starting at the district ranked as "1" and going down, until the overhang seats run out. Each districts resulting number x is the final number, that decides how many deputies the district elects on election day.
This method ensures, that those seats are assigned to underrepresented districts, at least partially levelling the artificially created disproportionality created by the section of reserved seats.
Seat allocation
The elections are done using the party-list proportional representation. If there is an electoral threshold, it is applied already in the first scrutinia.
First scrutinia
After votes in each district are morphed into percent points (marked as ΠP). Those percentages, if they are bigger than the threshold ( ΠΩ, currently set at 4%), are then used in latter calculations. Sum of all percentages, that passed the electoral threshold, are marked as ΠE. Seats are the distributed using the formula:
RP = ⌊(ΠE × x) ÷ ΠE⌋
Usually between 92% and 97% of the seats are distributed in the first scrutinia, with the rest being transferred to a second scrutinia for parliament-wide arrangement.
Second scrutinia
When all the RP have been summed up for each district, the remaining seats, marked as RR, are summed up nationwide, marked as RS. Those underhang seats are then given in descending order from the party with most seats to the one with the least, eventually looping from the least to the most again. Multiple rounds of assigning can be done before the second scrutinia seats run out. Those seats for each party are marked as RΠ.
After the alliances are set, it is decided, which district the candidates are elected from using the RR. Districts are ranked using the RR, from the lowest to the highest, and parties are ranked using the RΠ, from the highest to the lowest. Then, district ranked first in RR gets one additional mandate for a party with the highest RΠ (unless the party scored under the electoral threshold in the region). Then, the district ranked second recieves one additional mandate for the party with the highest RΠ (note: RΠ decreases with adding of mandates). After RR reaches 0 in a district, the district is removed from the list of second scrutinia adding mandates. If RΠ reaches 0, the party is removed from the distribution of overhang seats from then on.
It applies, that Σ(RΠ) = Σ(RR), so the last unassigned party mandate is assigned to the last country mandate, effectively filling all the mandates, while keeping both the vote and district proportionallity as set by the criteria.